Form-Based Codes? A picture’s worth a thousand words

If the attendees list of Placemaking@Work, my monthly webinar series, is any indicator, we’re increasingly united in our desire to improve the places we call home, wherever those places might be. Over time, I’ve had participants from Hawaii to Russia, from British Columbia to Saudi Arabia, and many points in between.

The common thread among these seekers is their search for tools and tactics that have proven effective. And increasingly dominating these conversations are form-based codes.

In preparation for a session on the form-based SmartCode, I started a #SmartCode tweetchat to get in the mood, and to engage the question I seem to receive at every dinner or party or event I attend: “Why form-based codes?”

It's not just people talking about form-based codes. It's an increasing number gettin' 'em done. Click for larger view.

It’s a valid question. People often tell me, “Things aren’t so bad around my town. We’re comfortable enough. Why would we want to consider the idea of a form-based code? Why are you guys so high on all this stuff?”

The simple answer is that our passion is helping communities change their default setting of unconscious, opportunity-inhibiting design and, time and time again, it’s existing single-use zoning that stands in their way. In response, form-based codes have emerged as a useful remedy, effectively legalizing community visions worldwide and serving as a bridge between their current conditions and the goals they’re trying to reach.

So, that’s the why, but there’s still the question of what. What are form-based codes? And how do they work?

To easily illustrate these ideas – the work of a lot of people over time, including the Transect Codes Council and the Form-Based Codes Institute – I talked to my brother and fellow urbanist, Steve Mouzon, about using some of his photos. Here they are. And, assuming a picture truly is worth a thousand words,  they’re sparing you a 10,000 word post. You’re welcome.

Click for larger view.

Above: A form-based code (FBC) is a blueprint for places where true community, in all its complexity, can prosper.

Click for larger view.

Above: To cities, planners, developers, and citizens, FBCs offer freedom of choice, quality of life, economic opportunity, environmental stewardship, and adaptability.

Click for larger view.

FBCs support community vision, local character, open lands conservation (as shown above), transit options, and walkable mixed-use neighborhoods.

Click for larger view.

Above: FBCs combat wasteful sprawl development, automobile-dominated streets, empty downtowns, and a hostile public realm.

Click for larger view.

Above: The SmartCode is a form-based, unified land development ordinance for planning and urban design. It assumes the role of what people typically call “zoning.”

Click for larger view.

Above: As a form-based code, it strongly addresses the physical form of buildings and development — their bulk and relationship to the street. Conversely, conventional zoning codes focus mostly on use and density.

Click for larger view.

Above: The SmartCode is transect-based, fostering communities with a continuous cross-section of habitats, from rural wilderness to urban city core.

Click for larger view.

The transect is divided into Transect Zones, each of complex character. This makes for diverse building types (as demonstrated above), thoroughfare types, and civic spaces.

Click for larger view.

Above: The six primary Transect Zones are T-1 Natural, T-2 Rural, T-3 Sub-Urban, T-4 General Urban, T-5 Urban Center, and T-6 Urban Core.

Click for larger view.

The SmartCode addresses development patterns at three scales of planning: Regional; Community; and, as shown above, Block and Building.

So, back to the original question of why form-based codes. Places, just like people, are dynamic, changing, growing, shrinking, refining, evolving. But the character of most places is unique, and challenged – rather than protected – by its current laws.

Just like a good friend helps you become more of who you really are, good development laws code for character. And that helps places grow in authentic patterns, building walkable community instead of placeless strips and pods for fast cars — the James Howard Kunstler Home from Nowhere sort of place.

A great form-based code extracts the DNA of a place and allows it. By right. And I don’t need a thousand words to say that making it easier for developers to build the things you want is smarter than making sprawl their path of least resistance.

Unless, of course, sprawl is what your community really wants.

–Hazel Borys

If PlaceShakers is our soapbox, our Facebook page is where we step down, grab a drink and enjoy a little conversation. Looking for a heads-up on the latest community-building news and perspective from around the web? Click through and “Like” us and we’ll keep you in the loop.

Comments

  1. Great article, raises some points I had not considered. It would be nice to know where the photos were taken.

  2. John Stimson says:

    This is an important discussion to have. I think one of the critical issues that needs to be discussed with planning authorities/towns/cities on why to use FBC is “what is the cost differential between using FBC vs traditional zoning both from an authority and an industry perspective?” I suspect that whilst the change to FBC is initially expensive (any change in system usually is) the clearer definition of what is expected/desired through using FBC should be cheaper than the confrontationalist approach of putting forward a proposal and defending it in the traditional zoning system with all the consultant and often legal costs. Has anyone investigated this?

  3. Thanks, Jon! These photos by Steve Mouzon were taken around the world. You can download these and hundreds more from his urbanism collection here.

    You’re right on, John. Any changes to the legal system take some initial investment, but for the places making that investment, the return is significant. I talk about that a little bit on this TEDx talk, and also go through a bevy of benefits on this Places that Pay blog post. The investigation is ongoing!

  4. Here’s where the pictures were taken:
    Miami Beach
    Broadway, England
    English countryside
    Huntsville, Alabama
    Philadelphia
    New York City suburb
    New Orleans
    Miami
    Segovia, Spain

  5. PlaceMakers says:

    Thank you, Steve!

  6. When I originally commented I clicked the “Notify me when new comments are added” checkbox and
    now each time a comment is added I get four
    emails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove people from that service?

    Thanks a lot!

Trackbacks

  1. [...] the end of that piece, I listed ten things that can go wrong with a form-based code. Later we dove into the first of those things: failing to articulate a collective community vision [...]

  2. [...] that shape our everyday community? We’ve talked extensively about when laws are rescinded to get in line with local character, or circumvented by [...]

Join the Conversation

*